If you sell building materials through independent distributors and dealers, you already know the frustration. You spend real money on marketing. Homeowners get inspired. Pros and dealers make sales. And then the trail goes cold.
By the time a board is installed or a window is set, you're staring at a shipment spreadsheet trying to guess which sales your marketing actually drove—and which ones were just the market doing its thing. Not exactly a compelling story for your leadership team.
Here's the good news: proving marketing ROI in a two-step channel is hard, but it's not impossible.
If you sold DTC skincare, this would be easy: Ad → Click → Cart → Revenue. Done.
In building products, especially through two-step distribution, the path looks more like this:
• A homeowner finds inspiration on social media.
• They explore brand sites, visualizers, guides, and reviews.
• They consult a contractor or dealer—who has their own preferences and incentives.
• A dealer quotes good/better/best options based on what's in stock.
• A distributor orders from you, the manufacturer.
• Product gets installed weeks or months after that first spark of interest.
The core problem? You don't own the transaction. You don't control pricing. You rarely know which jobs your marketing influenced. And your sales data usually reflects shipments out—not sell-through by project.
So when leadership asks, "What did we get for that consumer campaign?" you're left with soft answers: more traffic, more leads, maybe some anecdotal dealer feedback.
That's not enough anymore.
In categories like decking, siding, windows, and doors, consumers don't buy SKUs. They buy projects: a new deck for the backyard, a whole-house siding refresh, or maybe a large-format window package for a home addition.
So instead of obsessing over generic lead volume, center your funnel and KPI program around projects by asking questions like:
• How many projects did our marketing bring into the ecosystem?
• How many turned into quotes?
• How many quotes turned into jobs with our brand?
• What's the average revenue per job?
Once you frame it that way, the marketing funnel in a two-step channel becomes a lot clearer.
Forget the oversimplified awareness-to-purchase model. Here's what actually happens:
• Inspiration & Daydreaming: It starts with a spark. A cool Instagram post, a neighbor's new siding, a Pinterest board gone wild. Your job is to be that spark.
• The "Could We Actually Do This?" Phase: Homeowners get serious. They hit up brand sites, play with visualizers, and try to figure out if this dream fits into their budget. Your job is to turn their vague idea into a tangible plan.
• The Pro Enters the Chat: This is where dreams meet reality (and SKUs). Contractors and dealers translate the homeowner's vision into an actual quote. Your job? Make it a no-brainer for them to recommend your brand.
• The "Boxes Are Here!" Moment: Orders are placed, trucks roll, and your product finally gets installed. Your job is to make this process seamless and snag that sweet, sweet customer data via warranties and promos.
• Show-Off & Share: The project is done! Now come the proud homeowner photos, glowing reviews, and neighborly envy. Your job is to amplify this success to create the next wave of demand.
Proving ROI means mapping this path and connecting enough touchpoints so you can reasonably say: “When we spend $X on consumers, we generate Y more qualified projects, Z more quotes, and N incremental jobs at an acceptable cost.”
Perfect e-commerce-level tracking isn't realistic. What you're aiming for is data that's solid enough to guide your investment strategy and convince your leadership team it's working.
Most building products manufacturers have a website, a CRM, some kind of rebate, promo, or warranty system, and maybe a dealer portal. The problem is that these tools are rarely connected around how homeowners and pros actually behave.
Here’s how you create a practical ROI program:
1. Design digital tools around real homeowner behavior.
Visualizers, project planners, style guides, and budget calculators aren't vanity features. When done right, they generate project-level data on things like project type, timeline, rough budget, and preferred product styles, colors, and product tiers.
2. Turn anonymous interest into trackable projects.
When someone completes a visualizer, downloads a guide, or uses a dealer locator, don't just log a "lead." Create a project record in your CRM/CDP. That record becomes the thread you follow from first digital touch through dealer handoff and quote to job completion or loss. You won't capture every project—and you don’t need to. You just need enough signal to see patterns and trends.
3. Engage dealers and contractors with value, not just surveys.
If you want data from dealers and contractors, give them something worth their time: warm, well-qualified project referrals, simple ways to report status (quoted / won / lost), and incentives tied to sharing results. The goal is to build a program where sharing outcomes is a natural part of their workflow.
4. Use promos, warranties, and rebates as your data handshake.
When set up correctly, each time your partners register a warranty, claim a SPIFF, or redeem a promo, you can capture key details like project ID, product line, and dealer or contractor info. This sets up a direct line connecting your marketing campaigns to real-world results.
Instead of getting lost in a sea of spreadsheets, let's simplify. Here’s a three-layer KPI structure to prove your marketing actually works:
Layer 1: Business Outcomes (For Leadership)
This is the bottom line. Focus on metrics that speak their language:
• Incremental Revenue: How much new business did marketing drive in key product categories?
• Marketing Cost Per Job: What did it cost to acquire each new project?
• Premium Mix Shift: Are program members selling more high-margin products than non-members?
Example: "Dealers in our program grew premium decking sales 8% more than non-enrolled dealers."
Layer 2: Program Performance (For Marketing)
This is where you optimize your engine. Track what's actually working:
• Projects by Source: Which campaigns, channels, or assets are generating qualified projects?
• Conversion Rates: What's the journey from project lead to closed job?
• Cost Per Qualified Project: Where are your most efficient marketing dollars being spent?
Example: "Our deck visualizer is generating high-quality leads, while the inspiration gallery isn't converting."
Layer 3: Partner Engagement (For Sales & Channel Teams)
This layer turns marketing data into a sales tool. Give your team the intel they need to act:
• Leads Per Partner: Which dealers and contractors are getting the most from your marketing?
• Partner Win Rates: Who is most effective at closing the leads you send them?
• Sell-Through Trends: Are partners selling more product after engaging with your programs?
This data helps your sales team identify which partners need more support, who deserves more co-op funds, and who are your true growth drivers.
Most manufacturers have plenty of tools and ambition, but they often lack a clear, channel-aware strategy and the expertise to translate data across marketing, IT, and sales. That’s where we come in, bridging the gap and turning scattered information into a compelling story of value.
An agency with deep building products and channel experience should help you:
1. Map the real buyer journey
• For your specific category (decking vs windows vs siding; new construction vs R&R)
• Including consumer, contractor, dealer, and distributor behaviors
2. Define the right “project-centric” KPIs
• Not a 40-page dashboard, but a focused set of metrics tied to how you really sell
• Clear definitions everyone can agree on—from marketing to finance
3. Design the data strategy to match your reality
• What’s realistic with your current tech stack?
• Where do we need integrations vs smart workarounds?
• How can we leverage promos/warranties/SPIFFs without burning the channel out?
4. Build pilots and test/control structures
• Start in a region or product line
• Run clear test vs control scenarios
• Prove the model before scaling
5. Turn results into a narrative leadership actually believes
• “Here’s how our marketing created projects”
• “Here’s how those projects turned into jobs with our brand”
• “Here’s the incremental profit we created and the cost to do it”
In doing this, you’re building a defensible, repeatable story that earns you budget and respect.
If you're wrestling with the complexities of independent channels and a blurry line of sight to the final sale, you're not alone. The good news? An agency with deep channel experience can help you map the real buyer journey and define project-centric KPIs that everyone, from sales to the C-suite, can finally agree on.
Ready to move beyond "I think it's working" and start proving your value with confidence? Let's talk. A quick conversation is often all it takes to uncover your biggest opportunities and your most critical data gaps, helping you finally get the hard proof of your impact that you—and your leadership team—have been looking for.
Starbucks, Klarna and Uber are all rolling back AI investments. Why? Unexpectedly high costs, human rework and declining customer satisfaction have shown that implementing this new technology successfully is more complicated than just deploying software. We examine how companies are moving beyond the hype into the next phase of adoption.
As part of our celebration of Women in Construction Week and Women's Month, we sit down with Bethany Sanker, Interrupt’s director of client services, to learn more about how her experiences as a female leader have shaped her career. She shares how she handled the speed bumps, and her perspective on the benefits of recruiting more diverse teams in the building and construction industries, in this Q&A.
Are trade shows still earning their spot in the marketing budget? In the building materials industry it’s a no brainer, argues Strategic Account Manager Kyle Rhine. He explains that manufacturers still investing confidently aren’t doing so out of habit. They’re doing it because the channel continues to deliver— but only when it’s treated with the same rigor as the rest of the marketing mix. He explains how.